Shieldguard vs Signy of Highshield

Overall comparison

HERO	Fraction	Element	Type	Rarity	Aura
Shieldguard	Barbarians	Spirit	Defence	Uncommon	-
Signy of Highshield	Banner Lords	Magic	HP	Epic	-

HERO	LVL	STARS	HP	ATK	DEF	SPD	C.RATE	C.DMG	RESIST	ACC
Shieldguard	60	6	15360	705	1024	89	15	50	30	0
Signy of Highshield	60	6	20640 +5280	749 +44	1178 +154	97 +8	15	50	45 +15	0

Shieldguard	Uppercut Formula: 4*DEF Attacks 1 enemy. Has a 30% chance of placing a 15% [Decrease SPD] debuff for 2 turns. Damage inflicted is proportional to DEF. Decrease SPD 15%	Battle Stance Formula: 3.4DEF Formula: 0.2MAX_STAMINA Attacks all enemies. Fills this Champion's Turn Meter by 20% on each critical hit. Damage inflicted is proportional to DEF. Cooldown: 4	Mighty Soul [P] Removes one debuff from this Champion each turn. Cooldown: 1	-
Signy of Highshield	Platebreaker Formula: 0.12HP Formula: 0.2DEALT_DMG Attacks 1 enemy 2 times. Each hit has a 25% chance of placing a 50% [Decrease RES] debuff for 2 turns. Each hit also heals this Champion by 20% of the damage inflicted. Decrease RES	Highshield's Defiance Formula: 0.24*HP Attacks all enemies. Before attacking, has a 75% chance of removing 1 random debuff from all allies. After the attack, has a 75% chance of removing a random buff from all enemies. Cooldown: 4	Just Cause Places a 50% [Increase RES] buff and a 30% [Reflect Damage] buff on all allies for 2 turns. Cooldown: 6 Reflect Damage 30% Increase RES	Hero of the People [P] When this Champion is under a [Reflect Damage] buff and an enemy attempts to place a debuff, has a 20% chance to reflect the debuff back onto the attacker.